I've never tried the ice water, I'll do that. I want to try making the big ones again this year, just a dozen. I will try the ice water on them too.I love those state fair pickles too!
I’ve never tried making them huge.
I harvest mine at a fairly small size and put them in ice water overnight.
That seems to help with crispness.
I’d love to try making the big ones but the few times I’ve missed one or two cucumbers growing hidden on the vine they always are yellowish and seem to lose flavor.
You are lucky you have tried those state fair pickles. I'm stuck here in Canada day dreaming about them while I watch YouTube videos showing the food you folks have lol! No big pickles here that I've seen.. beaver tails and poutine is what I find at the fairs here lol. Good stuff though.