Shiplap or Feather Edge Fencing?

[cargoodrich]

Hello,

We're having a full garden makeover, and have been quoted for new fencing as part of this. The quote includes feather edge fencing panels. Is this the most durable fence panel, or should we be looking at shiplap or another type? I like the look of the attached fence, but not sure what type it is. Can someone help please?

 

[Tetters]

I know the feather edge is a stronger finish than the waney edge panels for fencing. Tongue and groove would be even stronger, but it would probably cost a bomb.
You can get a finish very similar to the above picture with feather edge - it all depends on the skill of the workmen I think.

It may be an idea to get a quote for shiplap like this ? The more quotes you get before you start, the better.

 

[Oliver Buckle]

I reckon it is probably feather edge. It is unusual in that the rails between the posts are square and on the posts. Usually they are arris rail, which triangular in section, meaning rain will run off better, and fit into holes in the posts. It's pronounced like a cockney saying 'arris tweed.

 

[cargoodrich]

Okay thank you Sounds like I'm best sticking with Feather Edge then.

 

[cntrlwagdnr]

Either shiplap or feather edges allow the wood to shrink over time, as it will, and prevent all the gaps. So if you want privacy, that's the way to go. Feathered would probably be more expensive as both edges are machined , but it does give a nice smooth look. You don't see that here, we mostly use rough planed cedar. When butted boards shrink they leave gaps, sometimes up to 1/4 inch. That doesn't sound like much, but as you move, it makes them pretty transparent for anything more that a few yards from the other side. Around here we use steel posts set in concrete, with metal cleats holding 2x4 rails.......... Wind! I wish ours had been lapped.

 

[Sean Regan]

I favour concrete posts and gravel boards with waney lap panels.
These are far more durable in that its easy to change the panels.

It's best not to attach any climbers to the panels, but to horizontal wires strung at intervals between eyes drrilled into the concrete posts.
One side of our garden has a fence I had errected forty years ago. I replaced the panels about fifteen years ago. It took about half an hour to replace all the panels that needed replacing.